Agamemnon and the validity of the trojan war

agamemnon and the validity of the trojan war The best overall treatment in english of the evidence for the trojan war is the revised version of michael wood’s in search of the trojan war (manchester, 1985) this is basically a mini series of six episodes that look at the finding evidence behind the trojan war.

The agamemnon is a classic greek tragedy written by aeschylus in which he entails the continuation of the curse on the house of atreus in the time period following the end of the trojan war and the return of king agamemnon. Agamemnon the leader of the mycenaean’s in homers trojan war is depicted as ‘the most powerful ruler of his day’-thucydides the peloponnesian war book 19 by thucydides mycenae was famously described as ‘rich as gold’ by homer in the ‘iliad. Jan haywood, lecturer in classical studies leave a reply to be sure, agamemnon and menelaus are far from the most celebrated warriors in the iliad troy engages in a wider historical dialogue on the reasons for, and validity of the trojan war the film ultimately refracts the homeric account of the war, reorientating audience. Certainly one of the most sensational news stories of the nineteenth century was the discovery by heinrich schliemann of what is now widely assumed to be the site of troy, the general public follows suit—and a good many historians today speak of the trojan war as something historical whatever its validity,.

Achilles' wrath at agamemnon for taking his war prize, the maiden briseis, forms the main subject of the iliad agamemnon aka atrides - greek king of mycenae and leader of the achaean army brother of king menelaus of sparta. Watch video the story of the trojan war—the bronze age conflict between the kingdoms of troy and mycenaean greece–straddles the history and mythology of ancient greece and inspired the greatest writers of. When paris took helen, the pact was invoked and the trojan war began agamemnon - the leader of the greek army at troy, and the king of argos, a city in greece upon his return from the war, agamemnon is killed by his adulterous wife, clytemnestra. It documents the final stages of the trojan war, which occurred around the 13th century bce it is written that it was king agamemnon of mycenae who formed a greek coalition and enforced a siege on the city that lasted a decade.

Agamemnon’s function in thucydides is different since it is affected by the general avoidance of mythological argument – especially in rhetoric – and its merely relative significance, the description of a war between the greeks, thucydides’ pragmatism, and his writing for posterity: aptly replaced by sparta’s dorianism in the context. The amateur archeologist, heinrich schliemann, went to mycenae because it was the home of legendary king agamemnon, leader of the greeks who went to troy to fight the trojan war schliemann excavated the grave circle of mycenean princes. Both in scope and type, consider the trojan war as similar to that between different european factions in wwi and wwii, or between the north and south in the american civil war: this was a seminal, history-shaping event, and an intra-cultural war: a war fought among people of the same basic culture although the two sides are protected by. When the trojan war began with the abduction of helen of sparta, king agamemnon called the myrmidons to arms although thetis tried to prevent him from leaving, achilles sailed to the beaches of troy to join the fight.

The trojan war was an epic siege carried out by the achaean (greek) kingdoms against the city of troy, around 1250 bc homer's iliad is a poetic version of events: part history, part myth. In a hittite text, around the time of the trojan war, circa 1300 bce, it mentions a city named wilusa, which translates to ilios, and a king called alexander, better known as paris it was also the hittite texts where ‘achaean’, the name homer used for the greeks, was identified. If agamemnon had the wisdom of a good leader he would have simply followed the rules of war and offered the girls back for the ransom by following these rules, the entire war may have been avoided, or at least delayed for a number of years. Aeschylus - the oresteia (agamemnon, libation bearers and eumenides) the oresteia offers the reader a close and intensive immersion with a truly pained universe of suffering : each play still has at its core a sense of flush of promise and vibrancy of athens.

The odyssey, describing the wanderings of odysseus after the trojan war, requires, too, a distancing between the poet and the trojan war, on the assumption. Divine presence in the iliad and troy 6 replies towards the beginning, you can see a conspicuous lack of divine influence a young boy questions achilles about the validity behind the stories, saying “they say your mother is an immortal goddess the disputes on olympus almost make the trojan war seem tame. Every student knows of the story of troy, the tale told by homer in the iliad thousands of years ago for centuries, it was believed that it was just that, a story, while the city of troy lay buried beneath the sands of turkey and the mythology of the past. Explanation: agamemnon was the fictional king of the ancient greeks in homer’s the iliadhe starts the trojan war after helen of troy, the wife of his brother menelaus, elopes with paris, the son of the trojan. Fall of troy vii: new archaeological interpretations and considerations inconclusive as to the validity of a historical trojan war it should also be noted, that if i am to stubborn quarrel between agamemnon and achilles, resulting in the latter's abstention from.

Agamemnon and the validity of the trojan war

The trojan war was the greatest conflict in the greek mythology, a war that was to influences people in literature and arts for centuries the war was fought between the greeks and trojans with their allies, upon a phrygian city of troy (ilium), on asia minor (modern turkey. The existence of a war in troy is undeniable however it is not the trojan war of homer’s iliad it is believed that homer’s account may have been based on a real event therefore having some truth but due to the mythological nature of the source, the unreliability of oral transmission and the exaggerated romantic theme, the account is not a valid source for historians. Ahhiya(wa) has been identified with the achaeans of the trojan war and the city of wilusa with the legendary city of troy (note the similarity with early greek however, robert s p beekes doubted the validity of this derivation and suggested a pre-greek proto-form akay w a. Talk:trojan war/archive 5 validity, they are all just relatively simple caricatures-- no scholar thinks that a person named agamemnon led this war.

  • Gods and heroes the iliad is an epic poem, written by homer, that covers the quarrels and fighting near the end of the trojan war the story opens nine years into the war, which basically started.
  • Their trojan favourites by agamemnon and his army, no doubt were a factor agamemnon's responsibility for his death springs from the ill will of his wife, his cousin and certain gods.

An obvious example is the story, referred to repeatedly in the odyssey, of how agamemnon, the greek commander-in-chief in the trojan war, returned home after the war and was immediately murdered by his wife clytemnestra and her paramour aegisthus, and how in due course agamemnon's murder was avenged by his son orestes odysseus, too, is on his. It identifies the modern political overtones of the trojan war myth as expressed in the film and explains why it found world-wide audiences editor and contributors are archaeologists or classical scholars, several of whom incorporate films into their teaching and research. Best answer: the iliad – homer the iliad focuses on one small part of the trojan war, nine years into the siege (homer's audience would already have known the details of how the war started and how it ended.

agamemnon and the validity of the trojan war The best overall treatment in english of the evidence for the trojan war is the revised version of michael wood’s in search of the trojan war (manchester, 1985) this is basically a mini series of six episodes that look at the finding evidence behind the trojan war.
Agamemnon and the validity of the trojan war
Rated 4/5 based on 50 review

2018.