Comparing and contrasting confucianism and legalism essay andrew simedru ms komar ap world history september 3, 2013 comparing and contrasting confucianism and legalism confucius once said, “the more man meditates upon good thoughts, the better will be. Confucianism and taoism have contrasting views on both religion and politics however, they stem from a similar goal and have similar beliefs confucianism is mainly centered around virtue and ethics as a means to an ordered society and believes that an ordered society is what people should strive for. Confucianism stressed the importance of achieving total harmony, obedience and order as shown in document 1 which is an excerpt from confucius’s “the small analects”, confucius states that a gentleman should learn to be faithful, trustworthy, and be able to take the blame for their mistakes.
About this resource this short handout compares and contrasts several key ideas and beliefs in christianity and taoism. Confucianism expresses polytheism in the way it holds a role for celestial gods because confucius’ system was man-centered and relied on man’s self-effort. Major philosophies of china confucianism legalism taoism the warring states period warfare broke out between nobles at the end of zhou dynasty led to period of upheaval and chaos people began to think about the best way to restore: social order harmony respect for authority confucius 551 bc- 479 bc known as kongfuzi chinese teacher and.
Although both legalism and confucianism are social belief systems, not religions, and both are intended to lead to an orderly society, their approaches are directly opposed. Confucianism and taoism are two of the most popular philosophies or ideals that are being observed, not only by native asian dwellers, but also by many people around the world while having some elements of religion, the two philosophies appear to contradict each other at. Confucianism became the dominant way of thinking and the later philosophy of legalism gained immense recognition as well each party had their own proposals for creating a better, harmonious society through the leaders, government, and individual lives of the people. A venn diagram showing comparing and contrasting buddhism,legalism, and confucianism you can edit this venn diagram using creately diagramming tool and include in your report/presentation/website. Comparing buddhism, confucianism, and taoism 4 compare and contrast buddhism, confucianism, and taoism legalism, taoism, and confucianism in ancient china philosophies dictate the most basic beliefs, concepts, and attitudes of individuals or groups, even entire civilizations confucianism and taoism have contrasting views on both.
Confucianism vs taoism (daoism) vs legalism a view of the differences and similarities of the three philosophies in ancient and modern china by matthew hoffman on 7 february 2012 tweet comments (0) please some people even have daoism or confucianism as their religion back in ancient days the peolpe of china relied on the thoughts and. Confucianism • mandate of heaven • confucius, mencius • hierarchical social order • benevolence • social relations • education and learning • filial piety • not interested in matters of spirituality • cultivate relationships between humans • philosophy • chinese • sought to answer questions. He calls legalism the iron scaffolding of the chinese empire, but emphasizes the marriage between legalism and confucianism  chinese law expert peerenboom compares han fei against the accepted standards of legal positivism and concluded that he is a legal positivist.
Buddhism vs confucianism diffen philosophy religion buddhism there are several similarities between the chinese philosophy of confucianism and the religion of buddhism however, there are some important differences as well this chart compares the two belief systems and their practices. In the table below, compare and contrast some the positions of confucianism and legalism on the topics indicated: aspect of chinese society confucianism legalism government was extremely important a ruler had to be good in order for his subjects the role of the government to be good and obey him. Both confucianism and legalism influenced the lives of its followers and the society in which it was practiced by developing contrasting and similar beliefs for example, confucius tressed the five key relationships to bring harmony and peace. While confucianism constitutes the bedrock of chinese culture, daoism, buddhism, and legalism also contributed to its development the overriding authority of the state and strict enforcement of the law are two of the fundamental elements of legalism. Creately is an easy to use diagram and flowchart software built for team collaboration supports over 40+ diagram types and has 1000’s of professionally drawn templates.
In a way, legalism tries to suppress the bad traits of human nature through harsh punishment, assuming that humans are inerently bad while confucianism attempts at bringing about the positive traits of human nature through hierarchy, education and social ritual, assuming that humans are good, but misguided (needing structure, ritual and. - comparing buddhism, taoism, and confucianism works cited not included the belief in some higher presence, other than our own, has existed since man can recollect religion was established from this belief, and it can survive and flourish because of this belief. One thing that confucianism and taoism have in common is that both philosophies focus on the goal of self-improvement in confucianism, the individual improves himself through orderly adherence with codes of behavior and respect for elders, and the reward is achieved strictly in this life.
Philosophical similarities for chinese confucianism and daoism (for a treatment of just the different forms this takes in china, see xinzhong yao, an introduction to confucianism confucianism, comparing descartes and confucius is harder than comparing confucius and lao tzu most of the other similarities build on the second one. Legalism emphasizes the proscribing of laws in order to ensure public order, whereas confucianism is more concerned with instilling morality both philosophies are very concerned with how to effectively govern a state, but they take very different approaches. Sample of completed venn diagram about three philosophies of confucianism, legalism, and taoism noting where to include similarities and differences among philosophies. Legalism was the approach that actually ended all the fighting, but at a heavy price: books were burned, and all free thinking was stopped people were not inspired by their leaders, but scared almost all crimes had similar, harsh punishments.
Best answer: all chinese philosophy have this in common - to better society thus, the underlying philosophy of each thought is the approach by which society and people would be made better confucius believed in the merit system which became a dominant way of thinking in china it basically supporteed th view that the wise must rule and hence, provided legitimacy to the emperor's. Confucianism, legalism, and daoism are the three main philosophies of the chinese people they have been the most influential and widely taught philosophies of the chinese for many centuries this essay will reveal the history of each philosophy’s origin. Confucianism and daoism are two of the most influential schools of thought in ancient china both are not only ways of thinking, but ways of life they are not religions: they have no teaching of worship of gods, or the afterlife each philosophy focus.